Winter driver fatigue could expose operators to prosecution, warns LMP Legal
18 November 2026
0
Natalie Middleton
Hazardous winter driving conditions and peak seasonal delivery pressures risk leaving operators exposed to prosecution over driver fatigue, LMP Legal has warned. The specialist transport law firm is
Hazardous winter driving conditions and peak seasonal delivery pressures risk leaving operators exposed to prosecution over driver fatigue, LMP Legal has warned.
Fatigue can affect drivers any time of the year but risks are higher over the winter
The specialist transport law firm is urging employers to look beyond basic drivers’ hours compliance and take proactive steps to protect both staff and their businesses.
Driver fatigue remains one of the most persistent risks on Britain’s roads. Research highlighted by road safety charity Brake estimates that between 10% and 20% of road collisions involve driver fatigue.
Although fatigue can affect drivers throughout the year, its dangers are heightened during the winter months, when wet roads, standing water, frost and ice can all compromise vehicle control and increase stopping distances.
Charlotte Le Maire, founder and partner at LMP Legal
Charlotte Le Maire, founder and partner at LMP Legal, said fatigue management must be a top priority as the sector enters its busiest trading period, with drivers facing intense pressure to meet tight schedules and rising customer expectations.
Her warning follows the Traffic Commissioners’ Guidance on Driver Welfare, Safety and Compliance, published earlier this month. The guidance reinforced the close link between driver welfare, fitness to drive, and legal compliance, stressing that operators must take a proactive approach to managing fatigue risks.
Le Maire commented: “Awareness of the risks surrounding driver fatigue has grown considerably in recent years, however, there is still work to be done. Many drivers underestimate the risks and potentially devastating consequences of getting behind the wheel when they are not fit to drive.
“Unlike alcohol or drug impairment, there is no straightforward roadside test to establish whether someone is too tired to drive. Yet its impact on a driver’s ability to concentrate, react and make decisions can be just as dangerous.”
Le Maire continued: “As a result, operators also need to recognise that the legal consequences of a fatigue-related collision can be equally serious for both the driver and their employer.”
Under the Road Traffic Act 1988, drivers can face prosecution for careless or dangerous driving, depending on the standard of driving and the circumstances of the incident. If a collision results in a fatality, the consequences can be considerably more severe.
However, responsibility does not end with the driver. When a collision happens during a work-related journey, investigators may also examine the employer’s role under the Health and Safety at Work Act and whether sufficient steps were taken to manage the risks associated with fatigue.
Le Maire said: “Managing fatigue needs to be treated as both an operational and legal responsibility, as well as a matter of driver welfare. Drivers have a responsibility to recognise when their health, medication or level of fatigue could affect their ability to drive safely and to raise any relevant concerns with their employer.
“Equally, operators can’t simply rely on drivers to volunteer this information. They need to create an environment where people feel comfortable discussing their health and wellbeing openly, without worrying that raising concerns could have any kind of negative consequences for them.
“The Traffic Commissioner has recently pushed the importance of looking after drivers and keeping them engaged as part of running a safe and compliant operation. Poor welfare can contribute to fatigue, ill health and, ultimately, non-compliance. It’s therefore vitally important that operators take responsibility for identifying and addressing these issues, rather than relying on drivers to recognise and manage fatigue on their own.”
The Health and Safety Executive advises employers to consider when drivers are most likely to experience fatigue when planning work schedules.
It identifies two particularly high-risk periods for sleep-related incidents – between 2am and 6am, and between 2pm and 4pm – and stresses that drivers should not continue driving if they feel tired, even if this disrupts delivery schedules.
Le Maire added: “When a serious collision occurs, the circumstances leading up to it will inevitably come under scrutiny. Operators need to be able to demonstrate that they have taken reasonable steps to manage fatigue, from realistic journey planning and appropriate rest periods to monitoring working patterns, providing relevant training and supporting driver health.
“This means looking beyond drivers’ hours records and considering the wider demands placed on drivers. Long or repetitive journeys, changes to working patterns, insufficient recovery time and pressure to meet tight delivery windows can all contribute to fatigue.
“Operators also must ensure drivers understand their own responsibilities, can recognise the warning signs and know what action to take if they are no longer fit to drive. This needs to be backed up by regular training and clear procedures that are followed in practice. As if a fatigue-related collision does occur, it’s those steps that will likely come under scrutiny.”